How the Compatibility Quiz Works

The Big Five Personality Traits (OCEAN) in a Nutshell

First, let’s break down those five big personality traits in everyday terms:

Openness to Experience – “Am I imaginative and curious?”

This trait is about how much you love novelty, art, and new ideas. High Openness means you’re creative, enjoy trying new things, and have a broad range of interests. Low Openness means you’re more traditional, preferring routines and the things you know. Imagine an open individual as someone who on a whim decides to try a Vietnamese-Icelandic fusion restaurant and then take a sculpting class – they thrive on new experiences! A less open person might say, “I have my favorite pizza place and my weekly TV show, and that’s enough for me.” Neither is good or bad; it’s just different preferences.

Conscientiousness – “How organized and dependable am I?”

This trait reflects discipline, reliability, and a knack for plans and order. If you’re high in Conscientiousness, you probably color-code your calendar, never miss a bill payment, and were that kid in school who started the project the day it was assigned. You take commitments seriously, whether it’s work deadlines or a workout regimen. Low conscientious folks are more fly-by-the-seat-of-the-pants – perhaps messy, spontaneous, and not overly concerned with rules. They might hit snooze a few more times and prefer to wing it rather than plan every detail.

Extraversion – “Do I gain energy from social interaction?”

Extraversion is essentially how outgoing and sociable you are. High Extraversion people are the classic “social butterflies” – talkative, energetic, and happiest in a crowd or a busy environment. They don’t just attend the party; they are the party. If you strike up a conversation in an elevator, chances are you’re more extraverted. Low Extraversion (introversion) means you’re more reserved, you enjoy solitude or small groups, and too much socializing drains you. Introverts might love quiet time at home, one-on-one deep conversations, or solo hobbies. It’s not that introverts can’t socialize – they absolutely can – they just have a smaller “battery” for it compared to extraverts.

Agreeableness – “Am I friendly and cooperative?”

Agreeableness measures your orientation toward others’ needs. Highly agreeable people are kind, empathetic, and helpful. They value harmony and often put others first – think of your supremely nice friend who always remembers birthdays and mediates conflicts with a smile. Low agreeableness folks are more straightforward, maybe more analytical or skeptical. They won’t bend over backwards just to keep the peace – if they disagree with you, you’ll know it! They might come off as critical or blunt, but they’re often just being honest rather than sugarcoating things. Agreeableness influences how we get along with others on a fundamental level.

Neuroticism (vs. Emotional Stability) – “Do I worry a lot or stay pretty calm?”

Despite the name, Neuroticism in this context doesn’t mean you have a disorder; it refers to how emotionally volatile or anxious you tend to be. High Neuroticism people feel emotions intensely. They’re more prone to stress – the kind who might lose sleep over a mistake at work or get really nervous before a big event. They experience the full spectrum of feelings (including the not-so-fun ones like anxiety, sadness, anger) quite frequently. In contrast, if you’re low in Neuroticism, you’re the even-keeled type. Not much rattles you; you’re chill under pressure and recover quickly from setbacks. You’re the friend everyone else turns to in a crisis because you keep your cool and reassure others.

Reflect: Where do you think you fall on each of these five dimensions? Most of us can identify our relative strengths. For example, you might think, “I’m definitely extroverted and pretty agreeable, but only moderately conscientious, and I do have my anxious moments so I’m somewhat neurotic.” Everyone has a unique mix – and that mix can subtly steer us toward certain choices, even the pets we feel drawn to.

Birds of a Feather: Why We Choose Pets Like Ourselves

It turns out people often subconsciously look for pets that fit their personality and lifestyle. Have you heard the saying that dogs and owners begin to look alike? Well, they often act alike too! Studies have shown that strangers can sometimes match dogs to their owners on sight because of behavioral resemblances and even appearance. We gravitate toward animals that resonate with us.

At My Puppy Pair, we take that instinct and give it structure. Rather than guessing based on appearance or personal preference alone, we use the well-established OCEAN personality model to find your best-fit breeds. You take a short quiz to reveal your Big Five profile. Dogs, of course, can't answer a personality quiz — but they do exhibit consistent breed-level traits that map to the same five dimensions. For example, a dog’s trainability contributes to its Conscientiousness score. High intelligence and curiosity? That’s Openness. An affectionate, sociable pup? High Agreeableness and Extraversion. And a highly reactive or anxious breed? That reflects higher Neuroticism.

So while the language of personality is shared, the translation is different: your scores come from introspection; a dog’s scores come from behavioral patterns and breed tendencies. If you’re a mellow homebody, you might not enjoy a super high-energy, mischievous dog – no matter how cute – because it just doesn’t mesh with your daily rhythm. Conversely, if you’re always outdoors and active, a calm lapdog might not keep up with you.

Let’s go through each Big Five trait and imagine the kind of dog that might be a dream match or, on the flip side, a potential mismatch. Of course, individual dogs vary and any person can love any individual dog – but when talking breeds, we generalize traits. This is about stacking the odds in favor of a great partnership.

---

Openness to Experience – Adventurer or Traditionalist?

If you scored high on Openness, you’re basically an adventurer at heart. You probably enjoy learning new things, exploring fresh ideas, and you might love pets that challenge and engage your mind. In My Puppy Pair, a dog scores high in Openness when it exhibits traits like high intelligence, curiosity, adaptability, and strong needs for mental stimulation. That means you’ll likely thrive with breeds that are cerebral, versatile, and always eager to learn. For instance, consider a Border Collie. Border Collies rank near the top in intelligence and mental stimulation needs – they’re problem solvers, trick learners, and agility champs. An open, creative owner could have a blast with that: today it’s scent games in the yard, tomorrow it’s freestyle canine dance moves.

Another strong match is a Poodle – famously smart and incredibly adaptable. Poodles love varied activities like swimming, tracking, and obedience, and they come in three sizes, making them a flexible choice for different living situations. Other high-Openness breeds might include the Australian Shepherd (mental and physical dynamo) or even more independent thinkers like the Shiba Inu, whose quirky, catlike nature appeals to owners who enjoy decoding complex personalities. You might even be drawn to rare or unusual breeds — not just for novelty’s sake, but because you enjoy the process of researching and understanding something unique.

If your Openness is lower, you’re more of a traditionalist. You likely find comfort in the familiar and prefer predictable routines. You may enjoy a steady, dependable companion that doesn’t require a lot of change, variety, or problem-solving stimulation. In our model, that might translate to dogs who are less driven by novelty, don’t require constant mental enrichment, and are more set in their ways — breeds that are content with familiar environments and consistent daily rhythms. These dogs may not be the most adaptable or intellectually demanding, but that’s precisely what makes them a better fit: they’re easy to understand, consistent in temperament, and well-suited to owners who prefer things just the way they are.

---

Conscientiousness – Planner or Free Spirit?

If you’re high in Conscientiousness, you probably approach dog ownership very seriously (you likely read dog training books before even bringing a pup home!). You’re ready to invest time in training and you’ll be diligent about meeting your dog’s needs. In My Puppy Pair, breeds that score high on Conscientiousness tend to be highly trainable, attentive, and responsive to structure — traits that align well with your planner mindset. Many herding breeds and working breeds fit here – these dogs are like the honor students of dogdom, but they need a good teacher. German Shepherds, for example, crave structure and tasks. In the hands of a conscientious owner who establishes routines, obedience, and maybe even gives them “jobs” (like agility or scent work), German Shepherds shine as loyal, brave companions.

Another high-conscientious pick: a Shetland Sheepdog (Sheltie). These are smaller herders, extremely smart and eager to please, but they absolutely need training and mental activity – a conscientious person will actually enjoy providing that. They’ll set up a daily schedule: morning jog, midday puzzle toy, evening training session – and the dog will flourish. It’s no surprise that research found very conscientious people often go for breeds like Schnauzers or Collies, which do best with lots of structure and attention to detail from the owner.

If you’re on the more relaxed, spontaneous end of Conscientiousness, you might want a dog that’s low maintenance in terms of training or rigid schedules. In our scoring model, these dogs tend to score lower on Conscientiousness — not because they’re “bad,” but because they don’t demand (or thrive under) strict regimens. You might not be excited about spending every evening in obedience classes or vacuuming fur daily (who is, really — but a highly conscientious person might just do it!).

For you, consider breeds known to be easygoing, independent, or self-directed. A great example is the Basset Hound. Bassets are adorable with those droopy ears and sad eyes, and they are pretty low-key. Sure, they may ignore some commands when they’ve caught an interesting scent, but they’re not going to punish you with hyperactivity if you skip a training day. They’re content to lumber along at their own pace. That independent streak means if you’re a bit forgetful or inconsistent, a Basset isn’t going to be neurotic about it – he’ll just shrug (in his basset-y way) and take a nap. Basically, if you’re a free spirit, look for breeds described as “independent,” “low energy,” or “easygoing.” They won’t mind that you don’t run a tight ship at home.

---

Extraversion – Social Butterfly or Quiet Companion?

Extraverts, you likely want a dog that’s as outgoing as you are. Picture yourself strolling through a busy farmers’ market on Saturday with your dog. A stranger smiles at your pup, and your pup enthusiastically wags back – maybe even leans in for a pet. This is your social accomplice! Breeds that love everyone and have energy to spare will match your lifestyle. A Labrador Retriever is a top choice here – Labs basically assume every human or dog they meet is their new best friend. They’re the ones happily splashing in the park fountain with kids they just met, or bringing you the ball to throw again (and again… and again) during a backyard BBQ. Labs (and Goldens similarly) are extroverts of the dog world, so for an extroverted owner it’s a perfect fit – you feed off each other’s energy.

Another great extrovert match is a Boxer. Boxers are playful, bouncy clowns; they will join any fun activity and often remain puppy-like well into adult years. If you jog or socialize a lot, a Boxer will ensure you’re never doing it alone. You’ll probably end up chatting with people who come over to pet your dog, which is exactly what you like. Extroverts also don’t mind a dog that demands a lot of interaction – in fact, they want that. So breeds that other, more introverted folks might find “too needy” or too energetic, an extrovert owner will adore. For instance, Dalmatians or Australian Shepherds are very high-energy, people-oriented breeds – an extrovert who’s always on the go can give them the stimulation they crave.

If you’re introverted, you might prefer a quieter, more low-key companion. You likely enjoy one-on-one time with your dog in calm environments, like cuddling on the couch or taking peaceful walks. A super boisterous, always-in-your-face dog might be overwhelming. Great introvert-friendly breeds are often those known for being calm or reserved. Consider a Greyhound. Yes, Greyhounds are large and known as racing dogs, but contrary to what many think, they are incredibly chill at home. A retired racing Greyhound is famous for being a “40-mph couch potato.” After a quick sprint in the yard, they are perfectly content to snooze for the rest of the day, ideally right next to you. They are usually polite with strangers (not overly effusive, not aggressive – just gently indifferent), which means you won’t be dragged into social encounters every five minutes like you might with a Golden or Lab.

---

Agreeableness – The Nurturer or The Straight-Shooter?

If you rate high in Agreeableness, you have a big caring heart. You likely want a dog that is sweet-natured and loving. The idea of nurturing a dog and forming a close bond appeals to you. You might melt when you see a gentle-eyed dog that just wants to love and be loved. Breeds known for their affectionate, people-loving personalities would be top of your list. Golden Retrievers are basically canine angels – friendly to everyone, patient with children, affectionate with their family. A highly agreeable person often finds their ideal companion in a Golden. These dogs will return all the love you give tenfold.

Another super-friendly breed is the Cavalier King Charles Spaniel (mentioned before for introverts too, showing how breed traits can satisfy different needs). Cavaliers are dubbed “love sponges” – they exist to adore their humans. For a nurturing person, that’s perfect. You can baby a Cavalier and they thrive on it.

A low Agreeableness person isn’t unkind; they just approach relationships more analytically or assertively. Such a person might not need a velcro dog and might even prefer a pet with a bit of independence or spunk. They might respect a dog that has its own mind. Chow Chows come to mind – they are famously aloof with anyone outside their family and even with family they are somewhat independent. A Chow will sit in the same room as you, but possibly on the other side, doing its own thing. It will be protective and loyal, but it’s not going to constantly beg for belly rubs. That kind of relationship might appeal to someone who values boundaries and mutual respect (a more low-A mindset).

Akitas are similar – they are deeply faithful to their owner, but they are not “people-pleasers” in the traditional sense. They have a dignified, independent air. Training an Akita or Chow requires a firm, consistent approach (traits often found in more dominant, less agreeable personalities). When you succeed, you earn not just a pet but a kind of partner who respects you, and you respect them. That dynamic can be very satisfying to the right person.

---

Neuroticism (Emotional Stability) – Sensitive Soul or Cool Customer?

If you’re someone who tends to worry or get stressed (higher Neuroticism), the last thing you want is a pet that adds even more anxiety to your life. You likely would do best with a calming dog presence – one that is predictably gentle and not reactive. Dogs can actually be incredible sources of emotional support; some breeds (or individual dogs) seem almost tuned into human emotions and offer quiet companionship when you’re feeling down. A breed like the Cavalier King Charles Spaniel (yes, them again!) or Bichon Frise could be great – they are cheerful and affectionate without being too demanding. A Cavalier will literally sit in your lap and look at you adoringly, which can be very soothing. Newfoundlands and Saint Bernards – although giant – are famously steady and sweet; they often serve as therapy dogs because of their bombproof gentle nature. Hugging a big fluffy Newfie who just calmly accepts all your emotions can feel like hugging a giant teddy bear – instant stress relief. Another route is an older dog of any breed – adult or senior dogs are usually calmer and easier, which might be ideal for a more anxious person (puppies, while cute, are unpredictable and a lot of work, which might spike your stress!).

One interesting tidbit: a study found hounds (like Beagles, Greyhounds, Basset Hounds) tend to be owned by some of the most emotionally stable (low neuroticism) people. Hounds are generally pretty independent and not overly neurotic themselves, so perhaps calm people choose equally calm dogs. If you know you’re anxious, you might avoid breeds that are known to be skittish or highly reactive (for example, some lines of Yorkshire Terriers or Italian Greyhounds can be very nervy). Those dogs might amplify a nervous household dynamic. Instead, a more nervously inclined person should seek out the canine equivalent of a zen master – the dog that just lies down and chillaxes even if the doorbell rings or if there’s a thunderstorm. Many retrievers, spaniels, and some mastiff-type breeds have this easy-going temperament (with exceptions of course).

If you’re very emotionally stable and little rattles you (low Neuroticism), you have the capacity to handle a more challenging dog temperament without it stressing you out. You might be the right person for a dog that others (especially sensitive folks) would find overwhelming. For example, Dalmatians are gorgeous and fun but are known to be high-strung and energetic – they’ve made some owners tear their hair out. But a cool-headed person with patience can manage a Dalmatian’s antics and not get upset when the dog is bouncing off the walls or occasionally stubborn. In fact, your calm can rub off; dogs often take cues from our energy. If you’re steady, the dog may become more secure too. Another example: Australian Cattle Dogs (Blue Heelers) – very smart but can be intense, nippy, and suspicious of strangers if not well-trained. They need a confident leader who isn’t going to be flustered by their strong will. A person who doesn’t easily get emotional can provide the consistent, even training such a dog needs, whereas someone who gets anxious or upset quickly might not fare as well. You might also be in a position to adopt a dog with a rough past or behavioral issues and rehabilitate it, because you won’t be discouraged by setbacks. Many emotionally stable, experienced dog people purposely adopt “difficult” dogs (like a reactive shelter dog) because they know they can stay calm and work through the problems, where others might panic or give up. It can be deeply rewarding for them to see the dog blossom under their steady guidance.

---

Bringing It All Together

So, what does this all mean for you on a practical level? Say you’ve taken a quick OCEAN quiz and identified your personality profile. How do you use that to find your furry match? Imagine a dating app, but for people and dog breeds. You input your personality traits, and it suggests breeds that could be your “soulmate.”

Note: Personality isn’t everything – practical lifestyle matters too! Your living situation, time availability, allergies, and overall routine will also influence the best breed for you. A high-energy extrovert living in a small apartment may not realistically keep a Border Collie happy, personality match or not. They might need to go with a smaller but still peppy breed (like a Boston Terrier). Likewise, an open-minded person who loves huge dogs might still have to pass on a Newfoundland if they live in a tiny 5th-floor walk-up.

That’s why My Puppy Pair doesn’t stop at personality. Once your OCEAN match is calculated, you can use our built-in filter system to fine-tune your results. Want a medium-sized, low-shedding dog that’s great with kids? You can filter for that in seconds. Prefer something high-energy but easy to groom? Done. The filter panel lets you sort by size, energy level, family-friendliness, and care needs so you can find a dog that fits both your temperament and your lifestyle. For users who want more precision, the Advanced Filters section offers slider controls for specific traits like Affectionate, Emotional Reactivity, Stubbornness, Sociability, and more. You can dial in exactly what you're looking for — whether you want a dog that’s cuddly and calm, or independent and strong-willed. It’s like building your dream dog with knobs and dials (but in a friendly, non-Frankenstein way).

So think of the OCEAN match as an essential piece of the puzzle — it helps you understand what kind of dog you’ll connect with. But lifestyle filtering helps ensure you’ll thrive together day-to-day. The wonderful thing is that with so many breeds (and mixed breeds) out there, there’s almost always a dog that fits your vibe, your schedule, and your space.

And if you’re adopting from a shelter, you might not know the exact breed mix — but that’s okay. Shelters often provide temperament notes like “shy and needs patience,” “great jogging partner,” or “loves kids.” You can use those cues just like you would filters, looking for dogs that align with both your personality and practical needs. Whether you're narrowing down from 150 options or trying to make sense of three pups at your local rescue, My Puppy Pair equips you with the right questions to ask — so the match you find is more than just cute; it's a fit for life.

---

Conclusion: Know Yourself, Know Your Dog

Choosing a dog breed is a bit like choosing a roommate or a friend – compatibility matters. The Big Five personality traits offer a fun and useful lens to understand what kind of human you are, and, through a little smart translation, what kind of canine might sync with you. Are you a laid-back homebody or a thrill-seeking adventurer? A disciplinarian or a free spirit? There are dogs that fit all these descriptions — not because they take personality quizzes, but because their observable traits (like trainability, sociability, energy level, and emotional reactivity) can be mapped to the same five personality dimensions. That’s the secret behind My Puppy Pair. You take a short quiz to reveal your OCEAN profile. The dogs? Their scores are calculated from breed tendencies — a Labrador’s high trainability and sociability translates to high Conscientiousness and Extraversion, for example. It’s a shared language, even if humans and dogs speak it in different ways.

Keep in mind, any individual dog can surprise you. Personalities vary within a breed. And environment and training shape behavior tremendously. A sweet mutt from the shelter, whose breed mix you don’t even know, might turn out to be your soul-dog simply because you click on a personal level. So use these guidelines as exactly that – guidelines, not strict rules. They’re here to raise the right questions: “Will this dog’s needs align with my lifestyle and temperament? Will we bring out the best in each other?”

At the end of the day, the best dog for you is the one you’ll love and care for wholeheartedly. That could be a gentle giant Newfoundland or a tiny sassy Chihuahua. The magic is in the match. When you find it, you’ll know – it’s tail wags, laughter, comfort on tough days, and years of companionship. And if using a bit of personality science helps you get there, then both you and your future pup are all the better for it. So, next time you’re scrolling through cute dog photos wondering which one to pick, take a moment of self-reflection. Get to know yourself – your OCEAN profile – and then find the dog who swims in the same ocean. You’ll be glad you did, and you’ll join the ranks of those happy owner–dog duos that seem made for each other.

---